Buffalo (1913-38) Nickels Coins: US Coins & Paper Money

Considered the “most American coin every produced”, the Buffalo 1913-38 coin has proved popular repeatedly. The majority of these coins were nickel, although in 2001 there was a re-mint edition done in 24k gold. Created by a talented artist, these works of art is proudly offered through our auctions. This period was very exciting for the U.S. with dealing the First World War and its aftermath. History was very important and continues to be currently as coin collectors are the historians of the commerce world. Whether you are collecting for personal or professional reasons, our website has what you need.

1918 7-D BUFFALO 5C NGC MS 64

Buy It Now: $91,875.00

Sale

Ends In: 17d 17h 55m

1927-S BUFFALO 5C NGC MS 66

Buy It Now: $89,250.00

Sale

Ends In: 12d 19h 16m

1926-S BUFFALO 5C NGC MS 65

Buy It Now: $81,375.00

Sale

Ends In: 22d 1h 8m

1920-S BUFFALO 5C NGC MS 66

Buy It Now: $62,475.00

Sale

Ends In: 19d 19h 47m

1937-D BUFFALO 5C NGC MS 66

Buy It Now: $51,975.00

Sale

Ends In: 12d 19h 18m

1923-S BUFFALO 5C NGC MS 66

Buy It Now: $34,125.00

Sale

Ends In: 5d 1h 10m

1918-S 5c PCGS CAC MS65 * Color * Buffalo Nickel

Buy It Now: $26,300.00

Sale

Ends In: 29d 1h 57m

1925-S BUFFALO 5C NGC MS 65

Buy It Now: $26,197.50

Sale

Ends In: 12d 1h

1928-D BUFFALO NICKEL NGC MS 67 STAR 3225653-008

Buy It Now: $25,500.00

Sale

Ends In: 7d 19h 55m

1918-S 5c PCGS Secure MS65 Buffalo Nickel

Buy It Now: $25,300.00

Sale

Ends In: 21d 17h 52m

1927-D BUFFALO 5C NGC MS 66

Buy It Now: $23,625.00

Sale

Ends In: 12d 1h 1m

1927-D BUFFALO 5C NGC MS 66

Buy It Now: $23,625.00

Sale

Ends In: 22d 14h 9m

1923-S 5c NGC MS66 * Color * Buffalo Nickel

Buy It Now: $22,100.00

Sale

Ends In: 23d 20h

1918-S BUFFALO 5C NGC MS 65

Buy It Now: $20,475.00

Sale

Ends In: 12d 1h 2m

1913-S BUFFALO 5C NGC MS 67

Buy It Now: $19,425.00

Sale

Ends In: 19d 14h 51m

1914 BUFFALO 5C NGC PR 68

Buy It Now: $19,425.00

Sale

Ends In: 23d 1h 6m

1925-D BUFFALO 5C NGC MS 66

Buy It Now: $18,375.00

Sale

Ends In: 12d 19h 15m

1913-S 5c NGC MS68 (Type 1) * Color * Buffalo Nickel

Buy It Now: $16,700.00

Sale

Ends In: 4d 2h 1m

1918 BUFFALO 5C NGC MS 67

Buy It Now: $15,225.00

Sale

Ends In: 12d 1h 9m

1927-S BUFFALO 5C NGC MS 65

Buy It Now: $15,225.00

Sale

Ends In: 12d 1h 37m

1936 BUFFALO 5C NGC PR 68

Buy It Now: $14,175.00

Sale

Ends In: 22d 1h 22m

1919-D BUFFALO 5C NGC MS 66

Buy It Now: $11,497.50

Sale

Ends In: 9d 1h

1919-D BUFFALO 5C NGC MS 66

Buy It Now: $11,497.50

Sale

Ends In: 17d 1h

FOR THE MAN WHO HAS IT ALL.......$10, 000 SUPER COIN LOT

Buy It Now: $10,000.00

Sale

Ends In: 14d 21h 49m

1935 DDR BUFFALO NICKEL VERY HIGH GRADE RARE FS-801 ERROR

Buy It Now: $10,000.00

Sale

Ends In: 22d 2h 17m

1917-S BUFFALO NICKEL PCGS MS 66 6655771

Buy It Now: $9,750.00

Sale

Ends In: 24d 11h 3m

1937-D BUFFALO 5C NGC MS 64

Buy It Now: $9,712.50

Sale

Ends In: 4d 18h 46m

1937-D BUFFALO 5C NGC MS 64

Buy It Now: $9,712.50

Sale

Ends In: 22d 57m

1937 BUFFALO 5C NGC MS 68

Buy It Now: $9,444.75

Sale

Ends In: 4d 18h 57m

1928-S 5c NGC MS66 * Color * Buffalo Nickel

Buy It Now: $9,000.00

Sale

Ends In: 23d 20h

1937 BUFFALO - 5 C, NGC slabbed, PROOF " 68 "

Price: $8,795.00

Sale

Ends In: 1d 34m

1936 BUFFALO 5C NGC PR 68

Buy It Now: $8,137.50

Sale

Ends In: 12d 1h 35m

1937-D 3 LEG BUFFALO NICKEL NGC MS-64

Buy It Now: $8,035.00

Sale

Ends In: 1d 18h 7m

1937 BUFFALO 5C NGC PR 68

Buy It Now: $7,875.00

Sale

Ends In: 12d 23h 58m

1937 BUFFALO 5C NGC PR 68

Buy It Now: $7,875.00

Sale

Ends In: 16d 1h 3m

1918-D BUFFALO 5C NGC MS 66

Buy It Now: $7,875.00

Sale

Ends In: 17d 59m

1937 BUFFALO 5C NGC PR 68

Buy It Now: $7,875.00

Sale

Ends In: 22d 1h 25m

1937 BUFFALO 5C NGC PR 68

Buy It Now: $7,875.00

Sale

Ends In: 23d 1h 38m

1917-D 5c NGC MS66 Buffalo Nickel

Buy It Now: $7,300.00

Sale

Ends In: 16d 9h

1918 7-D Overdate ANACS VF-35 Buffalo Nickel Looks XF

Buy It Now: $7,295.00

Sale

Ends In: 14d 18h 52m

1918 7-D 5C PCGS Genuine Buffalo Nickel XF

Buy It Now: $6,950.00

Sale

Ends In: 20d 1h 57m

1927 BUFFALO 5C NGC MS 67

Buy It Now: $6,825.00

Sale

Ends In: 1d 23m

1926-S 5c PCGS MS62 Buffalo Nickel

Buy It Now: $6,800.00

Sale

Ends In: 16d 9h

1919-D Buffalo Nickel Coin, PCGS MS-64

Buy It Now: $6,500.00

Sale

Ends In: 25d 20h 32m

1919 5c NGC MS67 * Color * Buffalo Nickel

Buy It Now: $6,400.00

Sale

Ends In: 17d 9h 58m

1916 BUFFALO 5C NGC MS 67

Buy It Now: $6,247.50

Sale

Ends In: 8d 15h 9m

1914 S 5C BUFFALO NICKEL PCGS MS 66 SUPER PQ++ NICE! TOUGH DATE! PQ+ EYE APPEAL!

Buy It Now: $6,199.00

Sale

Ends In: 4d 16h 19m

1923-S 5c NGC MS65 Buffalo Nickel

Buy It Now: $6,000.00

Sale

Ends In: 29d 1h 57m

1919-D 5c NGC MS65 Buffalo Nickel

Buy It Now: $5,900.00

Sale

Ends In: 29d 1h 57m

1921 BUFFALO 5C NGC MS 67

Buy It Now: $5,775.00

Sale

Ends In: 1d 21m

1915 BUFFALO NICKEL PCGS PROOF 67 CAC 6629613

Buy It Now: $5,750.00

Sale

Ends In: 7d 19h 5m

1918 7-D Buffalo Nickel, Rare Overdate, NGC VF-25, Original, Very Nice Key Date!

Buy It Now: $5,675.00

Sale

Ends In: 21d 36m

1920 BUFFALO NICKEL NGC MS 67 448213-002

Buy It Now: $5,650.00

Sale

Ends In: 7d 12h 52m

1917 S 5¢ Buffalo Nickel MS65

Buy It Now: $5,500.00

Sale

Ends In: 17d 15h 50m

1914 5C BUFFALO NICKEL PCGS MS 67 PQ++ GORGEOUS EYE APPEAL & POP. 19 NONE FINER!

Buy It Now: $5,499.00

Sale

Ends In: 7d 13h 33m

1916 DOUBLED DIE OBV 5c NGC VF ~ RARE BUFFALO NICKEL

Buy It Now: $5,495.00

Sale

Ends In: 19d 2h 1m

8, 000 PCS. 2 BAGS OF FULL DATE BUFFALO NICKELS SUPER BARGAIN FROM 1913-1938

Buy It Now: $5,200.00

Sale

Ends In: 6d 16h 28m

1914 BUFFALO 5C NGC PR 67

Buy It Now: $5,197.50

Sale

Ends In: 17d 26m

1914-S BUFFALO 5C NGC MS 66

Buy It Now: $5,197.50

Sale

Ends In: 19d 23h 55m

FOR THE MAN WHO HAS IT ALL.......$5000 SUPER COIN LOT

Buy It Now: $5,000.00

Sale

Ends In: 19d 21h 21m

LOT OF 50 BUFFALO NICKELS

Buy It Now: $5,000.00

Sale

Ends In: 20d 22h 36m

1929-S 5c NGC MS67 * Color * Buffalo Nickel

Buy It Now: $5,000.00

Sale

Ends In: 24d 8h 57m

1918-S CHOICE UNCIRCULATED BUFFALO NICKEL-KEY DATE RARE GEM FREE SHIPPING U.S.A.

Buy It Now: $4,950.00

Sale

Ends In: 8d 19h 44m

1918 7-D BUFFALO - TYPE 2 5C NGC MS 20

Buy It Now: $4,882.50

Sale

Ends In: 16d 1h 2m

12, 000 PCS. 3 BAGS OF PARTIAL DATE BUFFALO NICKELS SUPER BARGAIN

Buy It Now: $4,800.00

Sale

Ends In: 5d 17h 25m

1913-1938 BUFFAO 5c SET COMPLETE WITH KEY DATE & ERRORS

Buy It Now: $4,800.00

Sale

Ends In: 13d 12h 51m

1920-D 5c NGC MS65 * Color * Buffalo Nickel

Buy It Now: $4,800.00

Sale

Ends In: 29d 1h 58m

1916 16 Buffalo Nickel VF

Buy It Now: $4,795.00

Sale

Ends In: 7d 22h 21m

1913 TYPE 2 BUFFALO NICKEL NGC MS 67 348666-001

Buy It Now: $4,750.00

Sale

Ends In: 7d 12h 44m

PCGS Genuine 1918 7-D Overdate Buffalo Nickel LooksVF

Buy It Now: $4,500.00

Sale

Ends In: 8d 9h 26m

1918 7-D BUFFALO FIVE CENT NGC VF25! RARE + CHOICE!

Buy It Now: $4,302.00

Sale

Ends In: 10d 16h 52m

1935-S BUFFALO NICKEL NGC MS 67 1777260-003

Buy It Now: $4,250.00

Sale

Ends In: 7d 19h 20m

1915-D BUFFALO 5C NGC MS 66

Buy It Now: $4,147.50

Sale

Ends In: 1d 12m

1915-S BUFFALO 5C NGC MS 66

Buy It Now: $4,042.50

Sale

Ends In: 1d 1h 7m

1915-S BUFFALO 5C NGC MS 66

Buy It Now: $4,042.50

Sale

Ends In: 5d 1h 18m

1918 7-D Buffalo Nickel Very Fine INV#80-58 Great Detail on this classic 20th ce

Buy It Now: $3,950.00

Sale

Ends In: 13d 21h 42m

1913-S 5c NGC MS65 (Type 2) Buffalo Nickel

Buy It Now: $3,950.00

Sale

Ends In: 21d 8h 58m

1934 BUFFALO 5C NGC MS 67

Buy It Now: $3,937.50

Sale

Ends In: 27d 5m

1936 D 5C Buffalo Nickel (PCGS XF 40) 3-1 2 Legs

Buy It Now: $3,899.95

Sale

Ends In: 6d 2h 1m

1928-S Key Date Buffalo Nickel NGC MS65 ? Star Rainbow Toned Gem

Buy It Now: $3,895.00

Sale

Ends In: 5d 4h 35m

1917-S 5c NGC MS65 Buffalo Nickel

Buy It Now: $3,850.00

Sale

Ends In: 17d 8h 59m

1915 S NGC MS 65 BUFFALO NICKEL 5C BA52

Buy It Now: $3,800.00

Sale

Ends In: 9d 18h 28m

1924-D 5c NGC MS65 Buffalo Nickel

Buy It Now: $3,750.00

Sale

Ends In: 29d 1h 58m

1937 D BUFFALO NICKEL MS 62 PCGS 3 LEGS (#2275) Nice Certified Coin

Buy It Now: $3,699.49

Sale

Ends In: 2d 1m

1938 Rare Mini Buffalo Nickel

Price: $3,500.00

Sale

Ends In: 5d 7h 9m

1936-D 3 1 2 LEG 5c PCGS EF-40 ~ RARE BUFFALO NICKEL VARIETY

Price: $3,495.00
Buy It Now: $3,995.00

Sale

Ends In: 4d 3h 26m

1914-S 5c NGC MS66 Buffalo Nickel

Buy It Now: $3,350.00

Sale

Ends In: 29d 1h 57m

1928-S BUFFALO 5C NGC MS 65

Buy It Now: $3,307.50

Sale

Ends In: 22d 1h 3m

1930 BUFFALO NICKEL NGC MS 67 1723668-001

Buy It Now: $3,250.00

Sale

Ends In: 7d 12h 59m

8, 000 PCS. 2 BAGS OF PARTIAL DATE BUFFALO NICKELS SUPER BARGAIN

Buy It Now: $3,200.00

Sale

Ends In: 5d 17h 27m

Discount & Bargain

As a coin collector, you want the finest in service and in rare, quality coins. This is exactly what we offer you with our detailed website and terrific customer service. Our selection holds a vast amount of styles and years available in both printed money and minted coins. As popular as the Buffalo 1913-38 coins were, they have become rare in recent years, especially ones in mint condition, which were infrequently circulated.

It is our desire to bring you the finest quality selections possible. When you use our services, you know we are providing you with only the best. We have made it easy for anyone who is either new to the scene of collecting, or a hardened veteran, to use our services and locate the rare, quality coin that is perfect for your collection. You can even compare prices to verify you are bidding on only the best at the lowest price available.

Cheap